Horses and Ponies For Sale at Payne Farm Too, New Paltz, NY

More Than a Quarter of a Century of Excellence

Ready to Ride... Visit Our Sales Barn!

There is no more important decision than that of which horse or pony you buy. To make the process easier, the expert staff at Payne Farm Too works with you to present the horse or pony that fits the rider goals & budget. We provide stress-free horse shopping for your first horse/pony or your next riding partner with a wide selection of horses and ponies.

Pretty Sport Horse Gelding: Louie is a classic bay, 15.3h, 4 yr. old and is already 'novice friendly' with his quiet disposition and willing to please attitude. Nicely balanced with three comfortable gaits, cute over the jumps. Good form over fences. Good bone, Great brain. Has already been out Fox Hunting, participating in Jumping Clinics with Junior rider and Winning at the Horse Shows. Excellent out on the trails too. Simple enough for Junior or Amateur. He's already a quiet confidence builder.

More photos: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7

Willing to Please: Handsome 16.1+h, dark bay, 9 year old, Tb, gelding. Plenty of trail riding miles. Super guy to Hunter Pace. Successfully shown. Good manners. Pleasure to have in the barn and ride. Plenty of potential for a Pony Clubber too. Loads/ships, clips, bathes. Privately owned and sadly MUST SELL. $5,500.00/obo

more photos: 1- 2 - 3 - 4 - Click Here for Video

Been There- Won That!: Pretty 16.3h, dark bay, Tb, mare. Excellent manners. Has shown successfully from Florida thru the Northeast in everything from the Large Jr. Hunters to the Child Hunter/Eq., Modified, Schooling, Adult and Child Medal Classes... and more! Qualified her last rider for 2007 Eq. Finals! Was vet checked July 2008 and got the two thumbs up to continue as a show horse. Auto everything. Family hardship forces immediate sale. All serious offers entertained.

Fall in love! Jimny is a well-bred, handsome 2 y.o., Gelding. Pretty moving, athletic, intelligent, willing... endless potential. Sired by the famous WB, 'Primary Colors'. Train him and win with him! Peak at his photos! "Primary Colors" is known to stamp his foals with curious, friendly, quiet temperaments, huge, elastic strides and athletic ability. Priced to sell.

More photos: 1 - 2

Plenty of Bling: Sis is a pretty and quiet paint, 4 yr. old, Draft, mare. Professionally started and now W-T-C, jumping and trail riding. Stands tied to be bathed, groomed, tacked. Comfortable and fun! Come ride this beauty today!

More photos: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6

The Nicest 3 y.o. Ever: This flashy strawberry roan pony never ceases to amaze us with his ultra-quiet, willing-to-please attitude and pretty movement. He's happily been ridden in a rubber snaffle bit by the kids at all three of his balanced and elastic gaits. He's very simple! He carries some of the best performance pedigrees! Out of our 14.1h, APHA, "Dazzle" mare and sire by "Vogie", sired by "Rubenz". (imported from Germany, 1992, 16.2h, Chestnut, Oldenburg Stallion). He displays excellent gaits, conformation and temperament. This pony is bred to be a winning show pony! Priced so you don't miss your chance to own him- contact Payne Farm Too today!

Peter Jumps Everything: 15.3h, AQHA, 7 yr. old, gelding. Jumps everything. Has been cross country, hunter paced, trail ridden, Hunted, lower level Dressage and Hunter/Jumpers. Excellent ground manners, pretty mover, good form over fences. Versatile, brave, honest horse with the soundness, stamina and athletic ability you've been searching for!

More photos: 1 - 2

Lil' Sue: Cute as a button! 7 year old, black, 13 h, mare. Super safe- Great first pony.

More photos: 1

Striking & Stunning! Best bloodlines and plenty of talent! Fabulous bay filly out of an amazingly athletic and talented black/white paint Warmblood mare sired by 'Primary Colors'. This gal will steal your heart and the ribbons! Reasonably priced- awesome deal.

More photos: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4

Grover Seeks His New Rider: Quiet and responsive 5 yr. old, 15.3h, AQHA, gelding. Lovely mover, good form over fences. Loves the soft, light ride. Already started his successful show career- Always top three ribbons in the Hunters & Pleasure classes. A '10+' personality, good manners. Waits quietly and patiently at the trailer or at the gate for his classes. Marches right around the ring with no prep. Super show and/ or dressage horse, who enjoys hacking thru the countryside too. If you're on a budget looking for a super 3' horse - Buy him now and show him this season!

More photos: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5

Own Your Own Super Star: Flashy & Correct. Stevie was selectively bred by the farm and displays size, athletic ability and a quiet, willing disposition. He is sired by our own "P.F. Dudley" (see Our Stallion page) and out of a winning TB mare, who has been a proven producer of fabulous babies for us. This fellow is destined for greatness! Should mature 16+ hands. Reasonably priced sport horse prospect.

Jamacia: Great color, size and attitude. Super 2 year old, tri-color paint mare. Quiet, willing and intelligent. Priced to sell. Train her and win with her!

More photos: 1

Here's Your Next Winner: Big & Correct. This 10 month old filly is sired by the noted Paint Warmblood stallion, "Primary Colors" (visit Our Stallions page). "Primary Colors" is known to stamp his foals with curious, friendly, quiet temperaments, huge, elastic strides and athletic ability. Her dam is "Miss Maggie", an exceptionally well-bred Belgian mare. We expect great things from this gal. Her siblings are already winning on the line, in the show ring, dressage arena and eventing. Expected mature 16-17h. You couldn't breed this gal for what we'll sell her for!

More photos: 1 - 2 - 3

Sunshine: Pretty 4 year old, Palomino large pony.

More photos: 1 - 2

Lady: Flashy TbxClyde mare. Rides nicely and quietly in the ring and on the trails. Great ladies pleasure mount.

More photos: 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 - 6 - 7 - 8

Flashy Buckskin Pony: Good riding pony with plenty of eye catching color for the horse shows, trail rides, pony club- plenty of options for this pretty girl and her new owner.

More photos: 1 - 2

Sweets: - SOLD - Congratulations Alley!

Family Fun: Clyde is a fabulous family guy! Safe, kind and gentle. Lots of fun for everyone. Awesome guy to go trail riding thru the country side, fields, down the roads, etc. Good insurance policy as a school / husband / guest horse too. Click here for another photo